
By Ed Staskus
Emily Byrne knew Jack Hoffman from when she was in Broadview Hts. High School, although she didn’t know him. She was a freshman and he was a senior. Emily was hardly aware of Jack, seeing him only occasionally in the hallways as they went their separate ways. Jack threw an eye over her. What she needs is to fill out, he thought. She forgot about him the minute after whenever he passed her locker.
They ran into each other when she was a senior and he had long since graduated. She had started taking Barre classes at Prescription Fitness. “I remember you from high school,” he said, which surprised her. She thought back. He was a dim memory. He seemed to always be there, lifting weights. He would make small talk and encourage her to start weightlifting, saying that it would help her with body control, no matter what she was doing.
He was a fit young man, a gym rat. He worked out all the time. That was his main hobby. He was a beefcake and participated in physique competitions. “I work hard on my body,” he said. “You’ve got to dedicate yourself 100% to your training. Dedication is 150% of the formula.”
He somehow got her phone number and the next thing she knew started calling her. “We talked a few times. It seemed all right. We lived in the same town and had gone to the same school. Even though I didn’t consciously know what he was doing, I intuitively knew he was flirting with me. He was nice enough, but it was more irrelevant to me than not. I was indisposed to that sort of thing. He didn’t get it, but for some reason I let it go on.”
What she didn’t know was that it was a reason spinning down a road riddled with potholes.
During her freshman year at Baldwin Wallace University they started texting and messaging back and forth. Modern dating starts with a talking phase. You’re courting but it’s not exclusive. Nobody asks anybody to be serious. “In one way or another it got to the point where we were Snapchatting all the time. I got very much into him, even though it was all talk. I practically never saw him. It seemed like a mutual thing but I had a crush back, for sure. In the early days it was so much fun.”
Neither of them asked the other to make it a big time thing. “We were doing a weird limbo-like dance. We were together but not together. We were at that stage where it was something, although it was still not much of anything.”
He finally made a move and they made a date for the week of Emily’s spring break. The talking phase was going somewhere. “It was a big step for me since I was closed off to any kind of close relationship.” He was living with his mother in Broadview Hts. His father had abandoned the family for another woman years before when Jack was starting grade school. She was rooming in a dormitory on campus. They lived about twenty minutes apart and agreed on a restaurant.
She didn’t hear from him for a week beforehand. “I thought it was weird leading up to our exciting day, our first date.” She made sure to get a good night’s sleep the night before. She shampooed her hair, laid out a familiar outfit, and went over her conversation prep twice.
The plan was to go low-pressure, eat out, and go to a movie. “We had a plan but he stood me up. By the afternoon we were supposed to go out I still hadn’t heard from him. When he didn’t call I saved myself the embarrassment of being at the restaurant and waiting there for naught, so I didn’t go. I knew better.”
She had hoped the date would be a soft launch. It turned out to be a hard landing. “One thing about me is, cross me once, you’ll never have the chance to cross me again. He was finished. For what he was after, he was disqualified. I meant that with my whole heart. It was over for that man. It wasn’t a big blowout thing. It was just beyond doubt.”
He called her the following Monday.
“Hey, I haven’t talked to you in a couple of days,” he said, trying to gloss it over. “What’s up?”
“I called him out on it. He gave me some sad excuse that wasn’t any use.” She listened to most of it. “Whatever” is what she finally said. “I knew he wasn’t for me. It was not a good fit. He seemed to lack what was important to me, which was ambition.”
“Give me another chance,” he said, getting suddenly ambitious.
“I was young and I gave him a little bit of a leash. Attention is quite the drug. I let him continue to give me attention. We went back to limbo land my next few years of college. I should have stopped it, but I didn’t. Dumb and pretty, I screwed up.”
When they went back to what they had been doing, the talking phase, one cell phone base tower to another, it was a lot of flirting and daydreaming, no strings attached. He was getting some of what he wanted. To begin with, he wanted a girl to talk to. It wasn’t entirely clear to her what else he wanted. Emily had no expectations, like going on dates. “It worked for me. I wasn’t at Baldwin Wallace for its dating scene. I didn’t date anybody. I was hyper focused on my career, getting out of college and figuring it the hell out.”
Love can be a dangerous game. It can change our lives. It can ruin you or save you. “I had no desire to be close to men in that way. Unless you’re absolutely sure about it you have to fend for yourself. That might sound stoic and uncompromising, but that’s how I looked at it.”
She was at the campus gym one night and saw somebody she knew from one of her classes. “The guy stopped, said hello, I smiled, and he said it was the first time he had ever seen me smile.” It made her pause, but not for long. “College was a business to me. I wasn’t there to make friends. I didn’t have the luxury of failing a class or missing out on an internship for the summer. I needed to do whatever I had to for my survival. I needed to figure out how to get through my school days clean, dirty, and fast. Get it done, get out of there, and make sure you’ve got something lined up, because it’s off to the races before you even know you’re in the race.”
Emily was in the School of Business at Baldwin Wallace University. She had been offered scholarships to several universities but chose the school in Berea because the courses were taught both by academics and former business executives. There was plenty of hands-on learning. The student-to-faculty ratio was ten to one, which sealed the deal for her.
She kept Jack where she wanted him. “I wasn’t going to play the love game. It wasn’t going to get any deeper than the surface level.” What she meant was Jack could pay attention to her and she would accept his attention. She would take the male gaze for what it was worth.
The male gaze is structured by society for the benefit of men. It goes back a long way to Renaissance painting, classical Greek sculpture, and even farther back to Assyria. Middle Assyrian law codes dictated that respectable women had to wear veils in public. Prostitutes and enslaved women were not allowed to wear the veil. It was a barrier against the male gaze in public. It was a signifier, signaling which women were under the protection of a man.
“I didn’t have the space, the bandwidth, in my mind. I couldn’t allow him in. I wasn’t carried away by him, for one thing. There were some things I didn’t like about him, although I didn’t dislike him. But what I needed was somebody I could lean into. He wasn’t that somebody. He was in his mid-20s and still lived with his mother. There was something juvenile about that. I didn’t like it.”
Jack had gotten a track and field scholarship to Kent State University, but only lasted two semesters before dropping out. He later enrolled at Cuyahoga Community College but didn’t finish the first semester. He was a bartender. He always had plenty of cash and drove a white Toyota RAV4. “Everybody says I look good in it,” he said. “I like its adventure appeal.”
Emily wasn’t rocked by those kinds of adventure. “I felt that he wasn’t far enough along for where he was in life. I didn’t like him throwing away his scholarship. You have to make it happen. There is no option to fail. You have to figure out how to get out of the house and stay out of the house.” She tried to make sense of why Jack continued to call and text her, regardless of the scarcity of feeling she had for him.
“Most people at school, when they met me, thought I was older than I was. They thought I had a good handle on myself, because that is what I had to do outwardly. What I think he found so interesting about me was my energy, that I seemed to have figured it out. I’m not asking for validation from anybody. I don’t need that. That was the vibe I gave off. I’m going to keep moving by myself. I didn’t think he had much of that in him.”
Jack found Emily bewitching because she was buttoned up, not in spite of the buttons. She wasn’t a thousand and one emotions. He had his own emotions to deal with. “I couldn’t let myself have many feelings. I was tunnel visioned with school. My scholastic life was fight or flight. Feelings were obstacles. Emotions were road blocks.”
Jack was barking up the wrong beanstalk. Even if he had conjured up a family cow there was no treasure. There was no magical golden harp to trade for. “I kept telling him, I don’t think you understand. It is over my dead body that I will end up with a man like you. I mean, for real.” She was honest to a fault. “I don’t have what it is you think I have. And even if I have a soft side, it is not available for me to tap into. This is not going to work. Save yourself, find somebody else.”
After Jack didn’t show up for their date, although they continued Snapchatting, Emily didn’t allow herself to get close to him. She didn’t entirely trust him anymore. “You are so nice,” he texted. She ignored it. “You are so cool,” he texted. She ignored it. “You are so pretty,” he texted. She ignored it. They communicated mostly on social media. Jack was a presence, but not a physical presence. She only saw him a few times the next few years, more in passing than not.
“I was in school and he was not. I had to stay focused. He wasn’t focused on much of anything, except his body building. I told him, ‘I’m not going to date you.’ He had no problem picking up women. I was the woman who refused to give in, to validate him. I began to think he was a masochist, but then I realized he wanted me so I would give substance to his infatuation. He seemed to think, as long as he was in pursuit, no matter how many times I said no, the answer wasn’t no. He kept trying. He just wouldn’t quit.”
During her senior year Emily rarely replied to Jack’s messages. During her last semester she didn’t communicate with him, at all. “I knew one message from me and he would be up and running again.” After she graduated she rented a two-bedroom house in Hingetown, an emerging neighborhood for urban living on Cleveland’s near west side, sharing it with another graduate. She found a good-paying job with American Greetings.
She and her roommate explored nearby Tremont and Ohio City, which were walkable neighborhoods like Hingetown, home to contemporary bars and eateries, trendy boutiques, and pop culture. “It was great having a girlfriend to do things with. We met some men. It was fun. None of them needed emotional support from me. I made sure of that. I didn’t want to have to cradle anymore broken pieces because somebody’s father had abandoned him.”
Emily didn’t block Jack on her cell phone or on social media, but she didn’t let him know about her new address. She presumed it was over. She had little doubt she would ever see or hear from him again. She was wrong. He was a Jack in the Box. He was winding himself up. In the middle of an Indian summer that lasted into mid-November, a dozen Chrysler Imperial red roses were delivered to her house.
The card that came with the roses said, “Love, Jack.”
Ed Staskus posts monthly on 147 Stanley Street http://www.147stanleystreet.com, Made in Cleveland http://www.clevelandohiodaybook.com, Down East http://www.redroadpei.com, and Lithuanian Journal http://www.lithuanianjournal.com. To get the site’s monthly feature in your in-box click on “Follow.” More short stories can be found at Ed Staskus WordPress. His books are available on Amazon and Apple Books.
“Bomb City”
Cleveland, Ohio 1975. The John Scalish Crime Family and Danny Greene’s Irish Mob are at war. Car bombs are the weapon of choice. Two police detectives are assigned to find the bomb makers. It gets personal. Revenge is always personal.








